Delicious Flavors. Personalized Creations.
Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
It's All In The Batter!
Special Promotions
Select an item from our current specials!
No items to show yet
Check back soon for new items.
Cakes!
Order your cake size and flavor
Cakes
3 Layer Cake with Buttercream
$80.00
Tiered Cakes
$250.00
Smash Cake
2 Layer Cake
$40.00
Celebration Boards
This ultimate cake and cupcake combo comes with a 3 layer cake, 24 cupcakes, and cake topper.
$175.00
Pound Cakes
Traditional and Specialty Flavored Pound Cakes
$55.00
Cupcake Cake
Personalized cupcakes arranged in the shape of a letter(s), number(s), or custom shape. Basic topper (HBD, Anniversary, or Congrats) and decor included.
$50.00
Dessert Cakes
Enjoy one of our delicious 8" 2 layer cakes to compliment your next meal.
$40.00
Ice Cream Cakes
Enjoy a layer of ice cream nestled between 2 layers of our signature cake
$95.00
Specialty Cakes
Uniquely shaped cakes
$100.00
Cake Tasting Box
Sample our cakes for your wedding or upcoming event! Select 3 cake flavors and enjoy 2 slices of each flavor!
$60.00
Cupcakes!
Try our delicious signature and specialty cupcakes.
Signature Cupcakes
$72.00
Deluxe Cupcakes
2 Treats in 1! Specialty flavor cupcakes with cookies/fruit/candy/cake bite topper & buttercream
$84.00
Mini Cupcakes
$40.00
Treats!
Classic Cookies
Select one of our classic flavors individually packaged just for you!
$0.00
Dessert Brownies
Milk chocolate brownies decorated with candy melts and sprinkles. Deluxe Brownies are decorated with candy melts and sprinkles with add ons that include nuts, cookies, candy, etc
$35.00
Dessert Cones
Select a delicious cheesecake stuffed cone in your favorite classic dessert flavor.
$45.00
Dipped Oreos
Chocolate or Golden Oreos coated in candy melts and topped with sprinkles. Deluxe Dipped Oreos coated in candy melts topped with letters, candy, metallic embellishments, etc.
$35.00
Dipped Pretzels
Standard Pretzels - Rods dipped and drizzled with candy melts Deluxe Pretzels - Rods wrapped in caramel and dipped and drizzled with candy melts Premium Pretzels - Rods wrapped in caramel dipped and drizzled with candy melts and covered in nuts, toffee pieces or Oreo crumbles
$35.00
Parfait Shooters
Mini Parfaits in either Apple Pie, Banana Pudding, Cheesecake, Chocolate Brownie Mousse, Key Lime Pie, Strawberry Shortcake
$40.00
Dessert Box
Enjoy a variety of dessert to compliment your special event. Dessert Box includes pound cake slices, brownies, parfaits, and mini cupcakes.
$100.00
Treat Box
Create a box of your favorite treats.
$40.00
Themed Treat Table
Enjoy a themed treat table to compliment your event.
$200.00
Banana Pudding
Enjoy a rich and creamy banana pudding!
$30.00
Custom Orders By Name
Thank You For Your Custom Order!!! Locate your name and add each item to your cart. Select pick up or delivery and proceed to check out!
Signature Dozen Add On
$36.00
Deluxe Dozen Add on
$42.00
Catering Services!
FOR QUOTES EMAIL: LYNNEJONES@ITSALLINTHEBATTER.COM Include: Event Date Requested Item(s) Number of People Event Theme or Cuisine
Jumbo Party Wings
$40.00
Display Rentals
Cake Displays*
Enhance your event by selecting one of our exquisite displays to make your cake or cupcakes the center of attention! *Display rentals with delivery orders only!
$25.00
Table Display*
Enhance your event by selecting one of our exquisite displays to make your cake or cupcakes the center of attention! *Display rentals with delivery orders only!
$50.00
Mannequin Set Up
Enhance your event by selecting one of our exquisite displays to make your cake or cupcakes the center of attention! *Display rentals with delivery orders only!
$75.00